Sunday, November 8 Naples
Towns Advertise
The Beachside Resident
Search Log in Add your business Ask a question
  1. Home
  3. Naples
  4. Q&A
  5. Is it better to stay in Naples or Marco Island?
Town vs town answered from the site’s listings Frequently asked

Is it better to stay in Naples or Marco Island?

Naples 1 answer Oct 13, 2026

1 answer

In short

Going by the ratings of the hotels and inns in our listings, Marco Island edges it: its top three average 4.67★ against 4.57★ in Naples. Naples has 24 hotels and inns listed, Marco Island has 12.

Best rated on each side:

  • Naples Bay Resort & Marina (4.6★, Royal Harbor), Naples
  • DoubleTree Suites by Hilton Hotel Naples (4.6★, North Naples), Naples
  • Edgewater Beach Hotel (4.5★, Moorings), Naples
  • Marriott's Crystal Shores (4.6★, City of Marco), Marco Island
  • The Surf Club of Marco Resort, a Hilton Grand Vacations Club (4.7★, City of Marco), Marco Island
  • Club Regency of Marco Island, a Hilton Grand Vacations Club (4.7★, City of Marco), Marco Island
Naples Bay Resort & Marina
Resort hotel · Boat rental service · Marina
1500 5th Ave S, Naples (239) 530-1199
4.6
website
Edgewater Beach Hotel
Hotel · Event venue · Outdoor activity organiser
1901 Gulf Shore Blvd N, Naples (239) 403-2000
4.5
website
Club Regency of Marco Island, a Hilton Grand Vacations Club
Resort hotel · Club
500 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island (239) 394-8197
4.7
website
The Surf Club of Marco Resort, a Hilton Grand Vacations Club
Resort hotel
540 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island (239) 642-5800
4.7
website
DoubleTree Suites by Hilton Hotel Naples
Hotel
12200 Tamiami Trl N, Naples (239) 593-8733
4.6
website
Marriott's Crystal Shores
Hotel · Extended stay hotel
600 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island (239) 393-6800
4.6
website
Th
The Beachside Resident editorial answer · from the site’s listings

Your answer

Messages are published after moderation. We do not show your e-mail.

Similar questions

1answer Which is nicer, Destin or Fort Walton Beach? Town vs town Destin Frequently asked 1answer Which beach is nicer, St. Pete or Clearwater? Town vs town St. Petersburg Frequently asked 1answer Which beach is nicer, Pensacola or Destin? Town vs town Pensacola Frequently asked 1answer Which is nicer, St. Pete's beach or Clearwater? Town vs town St. Petersburg Frequently asked 1answer Which is better, Port Charlotte or Punta Gorda? Town vs town Port Charlotte Frequently asked