Is St. Pete Beach better than Treasure Island?

It depends on what you want: by our listings St Pete Beach has more going on — more places to eat, drink and visit — while Treasure Island is the quieter pick.

Beaches: St Pete Beach 11 vs Treasure Island 5

Restaurants: St Pete Beach 69 vs Treasure Island 20

Bars and clubs: St Pete Beach 38 vs Treasure Island 12

Hotels and inns: St Pete Beach 27 vs Treasure Island 19

Attractions, museums and parks: St Pete Beach 33 vs Treasure Island 10

The most-loved spots on each side, from our listings:

• Shattered Glass DIY St. Pete Beach (5.0★, Dolphin Village Boa), St Pete Beach
• La Croisette (4.8★, Corey Ave), St Pete Beach
• Pass-a-Grille Beach (4.8★, Pass-a-Grille Beach), St Pete Beach
• Treasure Island Beach (4.8★), Treasure Island
• Curious Soul Bakery & Coffee Shop (4.9★), Treasure Island
• Suncoast Sailing (4.9★), Treasure Island