Seafood
answered from the site’s listings
Frequently asked
Where do locals eat seafood in Key West?
Key West
1 answer
Oct 13, 2026
1 answer
In short
Away from the busiest names, these seafood restaurants in Key West score highest with locals and visitors alike: Red Shoe Island Bistro, Blue Heaven and The Lobster Shack Key West. Red Shoe Island Bistro holds 4.9★.
Well-rated places off the busiest lists:
- Red Shoe Island Bistro (4.9★, Key West)
- Blue Heaven (4.6★, Key West)
- The Lobster Shack Key West (4.7★, Key West)
- Cafe Marquesa (4.7★, Key West)
- PESCADO (4.7★, Key West)
PESCADO
Seafood restaurant · Burrito restaurant · Delivery service
1126 Truman Ave, Key West
(305) 396-7425 Open until 10:00 PM
4.7
website
Blue Heaven
American restaurant · Bar · Caribbean restaurant
729 Thomas St, Key West
(305) 296-8666
4.6
Popular place
website
The Lobster Shack Key West
Seafood restaurant · Restaurant
507 South St, Key West
(305) 741-7149 Closed
4.7
website
Red Shoe Island Bistro
Seafood restaurant
411 Petronia St, Key West
(305) 509-7271 Closed
4.9
Cafe Marquesa
Fine dining restaurant · Bar · French restaurant
600 Fleming St, Key West
(305) 292-1244 Closed
4.6
website
Th
The Beachside Resident
editorial answer · from the site’s listings
Similar questions
1answer
What is the best seafood restaurant in Sarasota, FL?
Seafood
Sarasota Frequently asked
1answer
What is the best seafood restaurant in Clearwater?
Seafood
Clearwater Frequently asked
1answer
Where do locals eat seafood in Cocoa Beach?
Seafood
Cocoa Beach Frequently asked
1answer
Where do locals eat seafood in Daytona Beach?
Seafood
Daytona Beach Frequently asked
1answer
What is the best seafood restaurant in Miami Beach?
Seafood
Miami Beach Frequently asked