Food
answered from the site’s listings
Frequently asked
Where do the locals go to eat in Key West?
Key West
1 answer
Oct 13, 2026
1 answer
In short
Away from the busiest names, these restaurants in Key West score highest with locals and visitors alike: Little Whitehouse Subs, Southernmost Pint Brewpub - Blast Beer Company Brewery and La Michoacana Key West Mexican Ice Cream. Little Whitehouse Subs holds 5.0★.
Well-rated places off the busiest lists:
- Little Whitehouse Subs (5.0★, Key West)
- Southernmost Pint Brewpub - Blast Beer Company Brewery (4.9★, Key West)
- La Michoacana Key West Mexican Ice Cream (4.9★, Key West)
- Square Grouper Key West (4.8★, Key West)
- Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market (4.8★, Key West)
Square Grouper Key West
American restaurant
920 Caroline St, Key West
(305) 292-1975 Closed opens at 5:00 PM
4.8
website
Southernmost Pint Brewpub - Blast Beer Company Brewery
Brewery · Brewpub · Gluten-free restaurant
522 Front St, Key West
(305) 647-7147 Open until 10:00 PM
4.9
website
Little Whitehouse Subs
Sandwich shop
218 Whitehead St, Key West
(305) 304-1470 Open until 5:00 PM
5.0
website
La Michoacana Key West Mexican Ice Cream
Ice cream shop · Dessert shop · Mexican restaurant
813 Peacock Plaza, Key West Open until 9:00 PM
4.9
website
Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market
Vegan restaurant · Coffee shop · Health food store
917 Simonton St, Key West
(305) 292-0043 Open until 6:00 PM
4.8
website
Th
The Beachside Resident
editorial answer · from the site’s listings
Similar questions
1answer
What is the #1 restaurant in Miami?
Food
Miami Frequently asked
1answer
What is a must eat in Miami?
Food
Miami Frequently asked
1answer
What is the hottest restaurant in Miami right now?
Food
Miami Frequently asked
1answer
Where do locals go to eat in Destin?
Food
Destin Frequently asked
1answer
What are some of the best kept secret restaurants in Destin, Florida?
Food
Destin Frequently asked