What is the best seafood restaurant in Marco Island?

Marco Island 1 answer Oct 13, 2026

1 answer

In short

Top rated in Marco Island, going by ratings and popularity: The Oyster Society, LeeBe Fish and Cocomo's Grill. The Oyster Society is the standout — rated 4.6★. There are 14 seafood restaurants in Marco Island in total.

From our listings, ranked by rating and popularity:

The Oyster Society (4.6★, City of Marco)
LeeBe Fish (4.6★, City of Marco)
Cocomo's Grill (4.5★, City of Marco)
Publix Super Market at Shops of Marco (4.5★, City of Marco)
Snook Inn (4.4★, City of Marco)

Open late on weekends: The Crazy Flamingo — until 2 am on Fri/Sat.

Early birds: Publix Super Market at Shops of Marco opens at 7 am on weekdays.

Closed on Sundays: Cocomo's Grill, The Crazy Flamingo — plan around it.

Snook Inn

Seafood restaurant

1215 Bald Eagle Dr, Marco Island (239) 394-3313

4.4

Popular place website

LeeBe Fish

Seafood market · Seafood restaurant

350 Royal Palm Dr, Marco Island (239) 389-0580 Closed opens at 11:00 AM

4.6

Popular place website

Publix Super Market at Shops of Marco

Supermarket · Bakery · Beer store

175 S Barfield Dr, Marco Island (239) 394-1086 Open until 10:00 PM

4.5

The Oyster Society

Seafood restaurant

599 S Collier Blvd #218, Marco Island (239) 394-3474 Closed opens at 4:30 PM

Towne center plaza, 1069 N Collier Blvd #202, Marco Island (239) 394-3600 Closed

4.5

website

The Beachside Resident editorial answer · from the site’s listings

What is the best seafood restaurant in Marco Island?

1 answer

Your answer

Similar questions