Sunday, November 8 Anna Maria
Towns Advertise
The Beachside Resident
Search Log in Add your business Ask a question
  1. Home
  3. Anna Maria
  4. Q&A
  5. What is the best seafood restaurant on Anna Maria Island?
Seafood answered from the site’s listings Frequently asked

What is the best seafood restaurant on Anna Maria Island?

Anna Maria 1 answer Oct 13, 2026

1 answer

In short

Top rated in Anna Maria, going by ratings and popularity: The Waterfront Restaurant, Sandbar Seafood & Spirits and Capt Anthony's Seafood Market. The Waterfront Restaurant is the standout — rated 4.5★.

From our listings, ranked by rating and popularity:

  1. The Waterfront Restaurant (4.5★, Anna Maria)
  2. Sandbar Seafood & Spirits (4.4★, Anna Maria)
  3. Capt Anthony's Seafood Market (4.6★, Anna Maria)

Worth the short drive from Anna Maria:

  • Kiwi Style Fish and Chips Anna Maria Island (4.9★) in Holmes Beach
  • Daiquiri Deck Bradenton Beach (4.6★) in Bradenton Beach
  • Sofra Kitchen Bar & Bistro (4.9★) in Bradenton
The Waterfront Restaurant
Seafood restaurant · Bar · Restaurant
111 S Bay Blvd, Anna Maria (941) 778-1515 Open until 9:00 PM
4.5
Popular place website
Daiquiri Deck Bradenton Beach
Seafood restaurant · American restaurant · Family restaurant
107 Bridge St, Bradenton Beach (941) 253-3300 Open until 10:00 PM
4.6
Popular place website
Capt Anthony's Seafood Market
Seafood market · Crab house · Fish store
107 Spring Ave, Anna Maria (941) 807-0071 Closed
4.6
website
Sofra Kitchen Bar & Bistro
Italian restaurant · Bar · Bistro
606 Manatee Ave W, Bradenton (941) 685-6095 Open until 9:00 PM
4.9
website
Kiwi Style Fish and Chips Anna Maria Island
Seafood restaurant · Bar & grill · British restaurant
3608 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach (941) 704-5040 Closed
4.9
website
Sandbar Seafood & Spirits
Seafood restaurant
100 Spring Ave, Anna Maria (941) 778-0444 Open until 10:00 PM
4.4
Popular place website
Th
The Beachside Resident editorial answer · from the site’s listings

Your answer

Messages are published after moderation. We do not show your e-mail.

Similar questions

1answer What is the best seafood restaurant in Sarasota, FL? Seafood Sarasota Frequently asked 1answer What is the best seafood restaurant in Clearwater? Seafood Clearwater Frequently asked 1answer Where do locals eat seafood in Cocoa Beach? Seafood Cocoa Beach Frequently asked 1answer Where do locals eat seafood in Daytona Beach? Seafood Daytona Beach Frequently asked 1answer What is the best seafood restaurant in Miami Beach? Seafood Miami Beach Frequently asked