Where do locals go to eat in St. Augustine?

St. Augustine 1 answer Oct 13, 2026

1 answer

In short

Away from the busiest names, these restaurants in St. Augustine score highest with locals and visitors alike: Thunder J's Pizzeria, Fire and Smoke BBQ Company and Anchor 28. Thunder J's Pizzeria holds 5.0★.

Well-rated places off the busiest lists:

Thunder J's Pizzeria (5.0★, St. Augustine)
Fire and Smoke BBQ Company (5.0★, St. Augustine)
Anchor 28 (5.0★, St. Augustine)
Sporks (4.9★, St. Augustine)
Kusina Colorado (4.9★, Anastasia)

Early birds: Bagel Base opens at 6 am on weekdays.

Kusina Colorado

Asian fusion restaurant

1480 A1A S, St. Augustine (386) 276-5242 Closed

4.9

website

Fire and Smoke BBQ Company

Barbecue restaurant

509 S Ponce De Leon Blvd, St. Augustine (847) 834-4410 Closed

4.9

website

Thunder J's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant · Cookie shop · Lunch restaurant

3915 A1A S Ste 105, St. Augustine (904) 347-9943 Open until 8:30 PM

140 Vilano Rd Ste B, St. Augustine (904) 615-1943 Open until 9:00 PM

5.0

website

Sporks

Eclectic restaurant · Caterer

1943 A1A S, St. Augustine (904) 342-8772 Closed

4.9

website

The Beachside Resident editorial answer · from the site’s listings

Where do locals go to eat in St. Augustine?

1 answer

Your answer

Similar questions